Essential Guide

Guide to Unified Communications as a Service: Making sense of it all

A comprehensive collection of articles, videos and more, hand-picked by our editors

On-premises vs. hosted cloud UC: Comparison chart

This tech comparison offers an in-depth look at cloud UC to help you decide whether to stick with on-premises or opt for hosted cloud.

Ever since hosted UC came on the scene, businesses have started opting out of their on-premises (on-prem) UC solutions and replacing them with cloud-based UC options. Before you make the plunge into the world of hosted cloud UC, however, it is advisable to compare and contrast the two in order to determine whether you're making the right decision. 

Areas that vary depending on which solution you deploy include cost, installation, maintenance, disaster recovery (DR) options and more -- all of which deserve some scrutinizing before committing to either on-prem or hosted UC.

The following chart compares these two alternatives. It offers you a quick and easy way to evaluate the pros and cons of each and helps you decide which is best for your business.

 

Hosted UC

On-prem UC

Capital expenditure (CAPEX costs)

Low CAPEX costs. No hardware costs -- except for phones.

The larger the enterprise, the greater the CAPEX costs. Expenses include phone hardware, rack space, power, cooling, etc.

Installation costs

Low installation costs because little/no hardware needs installing.

High installation costs because hardware needs to be installed and staff/contractors need to be paid.

Migration strategy

IT teams can add new UC features alongside existing communications systems to evaluate deployments. New UC features/services can be readily available, allowing IT to roll out new functionality at will.

IT teams usually must rip and replace existing infrastructure. This can result in communication downtime and troubleshooting. On-prem solutions can take months, even years, to roll out company-wide.

Infrastructure required

The hosted infrastructure required to provide UC functions (chat, presence, etc.) resides in the data center of your service provider. Your IP connection to the cloud allows users to access that functionality. Back-end infrastructure is all bundled in a monthly fee.

On-prem infrastructure may vary by vendor but will typically include: proprietary control units to house analog telephony boards; server(s) for hosting voicemail; UC functions (chat, presence, etc.); and sometimes management/administration functions.

Provisioning requirements

Landline connectivity is provided in the cloud. So, there is one less contract to worry about -- since the cost of this connectivity is bundled into your per-user fee.

For in/outbound calling, IT must provision (in blocks of 23) analog land lines, which can be provided by a full T1 circuit that requires a telephone company contract.

Licensing

Providers typically charge a per-user licensing fee.

Licensing is more granular and complex. There are OPEX costs for software maintenance on the license to ensure support and functionality upgrades.

Maintenance and updates

 

Software updates are maintained by the cloud provider, so subscribers will always be up to date.

 

Updating features may need to be repeated a number of times, depending on the architecture of the on-prem solution. Upgrades or feature enhancements can take months or even years.

 

Total cost of ownership (TCO)

Host UC TCO savings can be substantial.

On-prem UC TCO costs are much higher than hosted UC.

Disaster recovery (DR)

Hosted UC makes you reliant on your Internet link and hosting service. Most providers do offer reliable redundancy. One con is you don't have immediate access to your equipment like you would with on-prem UC.

It can be expensive to include redundancy into on-prem UC. Only larger enterprises can typically afford investing in DR. One pro is that you have access to equipment for troubleshooting at any time.

For more information, read our tip on the advantages of UCaaS.

This was last published in April 2013

PRO+

Content

Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.

Essential Guide

Guide to Unified Communications as a Service: Making sense of it all

Join the conversation

3 comments

Send me notifications when other members comment.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy

Please create a username to comment.

The cloud is not a magic happy place where everything works all the time. The cloud is just a server room somewhere else. Hardware needs replaced, software needs updated. Everything that needs to be done on Prem, needs to be done in the cloud. The end of story question is, can the cloud providers staff do it for a lower cost then then staff on prem.
Cancel
@ BLThomas - Actually, the Cloud story is just beginning. It is much more than one "server room somewhere else". If the provider is truly a Cloud Provider, there are many servers in multiple "somewhere else"s. They provide security and true business continuity that few large enterprise businesses and even fewer small-midsize businesses can afford - or effectively manage.

The beauty of the Cloud, whether it is Desktop as a Service, Software as a Service, or Unified Communications as a Service is that the cost of all the redundancies and software maintenance (and upgrades, additional features, and training, and...) are cost-shared across multiple customer organizations. So, to answer to your question - yes even for large enterprises, we can almost always win the Total Cost of Ownership comparison against an on-premise system.
Cancel
Cloud is probably the most abused tech term. Although I understand the intent of the article, I think we need to explicit about type of offering rather than just saying "on-prem vs cloud  UC". In this article, author really intent to say "on prem vs SaaS UC offering". There may also be a possibly that customer still manages their own instance of UC software deployed in IaaS (AWS, Azure etc.) - just replace own DC with IaaS. In that case, almost all points mentioned will be applicable in the same way as on-prem deployment
Cancel

-ADS BY GOOGLE

SearchCRM

SearchNetworking

SearchSDN

SearchTelecom

SearchITChannel

Close